Social Media - Good or Bad for your Brand?

Posted on 12 August 2008

With the increasing uptake of social media sites such as Digg, Technorati, Slashdot, YouTube and MySpace, together with community bookmarking sites like Del.icio.us, Reddit and Ma.gnolia, companies the world over can reach their target markets via a whole new channel.

Social networking is like viral marketing on steroids. Companies can release a new product in the morning and have it talked about by millions of users on thousands of sites by the afternoon.

Look at the bottom of this article and you’ll find a number of small icons - clicking these will allow you to share this article on your favourite bookmarking and social media sites. This is the kind of tool we’re talking about here - just give it a try and see how powerful it is.

The good news is that social media is user driven. The bad news is that social media is user driven. Yes, there’s the rub. Users are fickle creatures - they can love a product one minute and then drop it like a lead balloon the next, depending on their experience with the product, a rumor, or whether they have had their morning coffee yet. And if their experience is bad, the noise is generally louder. To protect their reputations it’s not just journalists that companies have to impress these days. It’s anyone with a computer and an Internet connection. Love it or hate it, the user community now has enormous power over the online reputation of a company or brand.

Not surprisingly, businesses and individuals alike clamor for the attention and mostly enjoy the limelight that social media can bring. Others hate the intense scrutiny that often accompanies the popularity. An example is usability blogger Kim Krause Berg’s unpleasant first experience of Digg - I Don’t Digg Being Dugg.

Online communities can even bring a site to its knees. Marketers are calling it the “Digg Effect” or the “Slashdot Effect”. Buzz for a site can cause more than good or bad publicity. As Kim found out, the effect can cause traffic overload sometimes resulting in site downtime and lost business.

Social media can also kill the reputation of a brand instantly. Take the Microsoft Windows Vista Laptop Scandal for instance. No stranger to the benefits of social media, Microsoft had allegedly tried to exploit the power of the blogosphere at the end of last year, by sending a number of A-list bloggers a free Acer Ferrari laptop loaded with the yet-to-be-released Windows Vista and Office 2007.

The pitch was a request for the bloggers to “review” the new Windows software in their influential blogs. Many bloggers did write a review, but some did not disclose their free gift. When this fact was discovered later, the bloggers were hammered by large portions of the blogosphere for what they saw as a clear conflict of interest. Microsoft were tagged both literally and figuratively as bribers and Windows Vista was widely panned with parody tag lines such as “Vista: So Bad We Had to Give it Away”. Not a great start to an online product release.

Another example of the damage that social networking can do to a company’s online reputation is the National Pork Board of America’s recent battle with breastfeeding advocate and well-known blogger Jennifer Laycock. Jennifer was sent a harshly worded letter from the Pork Board’s representing counsel, threatening her with legal action for allegedly stealing their pro-pork slogan “Pork: The Other White Meat” in a pro-breastfeeding t-shirt she had designed that read “The Other White Milk”.

The letter suggested that their case for trademark infringement was probably solid. Unfortunately for the Pork Board, the poorly-worded letter also suggested that they were insensitive to breastfeeding mothers and the plight of starving infants. The Pork Board didn’t count on Jennifer’s influence in the blogosphere and the power of social networking to carry her defiant response to the world. The Pork Board ended up receiving bags of hate mail and thousands of flame emails via their online contact form, forcing them to issue a public apology to Jennifer from the Board’s CEO and a generous donation to the Mother’s Milk Bank of Ohio in order to save face.

To their credit, the Pork Board did the right thing. They also made sure that all persons who complained about their approach to Jennifer received a polite, measured email response from the CEO. As a former PR consultant myself, I tip my hat at them. Having the apology come from the very top is smart. It demonstrates how seriously they took the complaints. The wording of the complainant response is polite and restrained. Addressing each and every complainer personally is impressive. It would’ve been tempting to ignore all the flames and issue some stock standard release.

Their choice of legal team may have been questionable, but the Pork Board’s public relations team mobilized quickly, upgraded to full damage control mode and did a great job of mopping up the PR mess before it spread too far. Social media might have damaged them, but the Pork Board’s reputation was ultimately salvaged by quick thinking and a swift online response.

Such situations underscore the growing importance of online reputation management (ORM) in our Web 2.0, social media-driven world. Companies should be tracking their online reputation on a daily basis to check for negative commentary via social media in order to avert potential PR disasters. Major search marketing players such as Andy Beal recognized the potential growth in ORM a long time ago. But I wonder how many PR/Search Marketing agencies currently offer this service?

With brand reputation increasingly at risk, you can be sure the smart agencies will be adding ORM to their service offerings faster than you can say “Can you Digg it?”

About the Author: Kalena Jordan

Kalena Jordan is one of the first search engine optimization experts in Australia, who is well known and respected in the industry, particularly in the U.S. As well as running a daily Search Engine Advice Column, Kalena manages Search Engine College - an online training institution offering instructor-led short courses and downloadable self-study courses in Search Engine Optimization and other Search Engine Marketing subjects.

[co.mments] [del.icio.us] [Digg] [Furl] [Google] [Mixx] [MySpace] [StumbleUpon] [Windows Live] [Yahoo!] [Email]

This post was written by:

seosu - who has written 15 posts on SeoSU.com.


Contact the author

16 Comments For This Post

  1. adda4u says:

    My Personal Opinion

    I feel social Media is a good thing for stay connecting with each other and it will help us to get some quality traffic to web site

    They are very good if we use properly ….

    -Sri-

  2. Domestic01 says:

    I’m surprised that social networking along with social media has only really exploded recently when you think about the other great advancements and trends the rest of the internet and technology has made in recent years.

    In saying that though I agree with Sri that if used properly and not hastily social media is a very good thing.

  3. seosu says:

    Hi Domestic, I agree that it is quite surprising that Social Media has only recently exploded… but I think in the past it was being restricted by a number of things, accessibility to the Internet being the biggest factor.

    Now with more and more people having access all over the world, plus accessibility to broadband getting better is allowing SM to really flourish. I think what we are seeing now is just the begining. Social Media is just as big as email was back in the day. We’re yet to see how far Social Media/ Networking will actually go in terms of doing business online.

  4. sarinpankaj says:

    Social medium is a great way to accomplish the following tasks:

    - Increase web traffic.
    - Cross utilize the business in case of collobration. For example adsence clicks and reviewing websites
    - Finally, a commonplace for web geeks

  5. anant shrivastava says:

    few points from my side,

    first you missed stumbleupon in the main list which out to be among the top.

    although it may sound as a disadvantage at first that the whole hype of social media is user driven, but that’s the power and beauty of it.

    this simple fact that people shift their focus every movement is a natural fact which is shown now in the web also.

  6. Games says:

    Social media is all over web 2.0 and I think it’s the best way to reach our target audience. Social media is so popular these days that it has changed the face of marketing.

  7. farhansalehzaea says:

    i think social media is a good and only users may drive it otherwise…..
    and also social book marking is the good way to earn online

  8. simakas says:

    I have never thought that social networking along with social media has only really exploded recently when you think about the other great advancements and trends the rest of the internet and technology has made in recent years.

    So i am saying that social media is very good thing

  9. lancelot says:

    The social media has been an emerging factor in business. The very fact that there are people reading this suggest that people do take the blogs seriously. an active participation from the community has ensured that the social media will play a major role in determining the fate of new products released..

  10. kash says:

    In my opinion, social media is good for generating more traffic, which turns in more customers. If one product/service is good, it will certainly got positive reputation more than the bad comments & vice versa.

    As internet evolving, new horizon of money making opportunities are approaching to the skilled persons… ORM is also one of that… :)

  11. Hakosho says:

    I think that copyright is overused these days, Even though someone uses the same tag or URL as you, such as toyota.us. It should be whats the content is weather or not you take action toward a person or group. The idea behind this is if you like what the idea they are using your name on, If you like it let them use it but ask them to remember that it is yours. On the other side if they have something you don’t like. Legal action could be taken toward them.

  12. Aitezaz says:

    I think the social media is good for selling or buying products but people not know how it is to use. but it is very useful if any body know it.

  13. Khan says:

    No one can deny the power of social networking sites. It’s a great source of generating quick and targeted traffic to your website. However, many people complain that such traffic do not convert very well. In my opinion, it depends on website owner to motivate its visitor to make a move like buying some product.

  14. Farrukh says:

    I think the most important think that social marketing can generate traffic on web site.If u selling a good produt or givig any servise than more customers on your site.But it the responsibility that how to handle the traffic on site.

  15. noni khan says:

    In my opinion its very useful tool or you can say resource for any site, no matter what niche or category your website falls but marketing your site on social media sites brings in lots of quality traffic and let your brand become known in quick time. so all in all its a positive tool for any business or website.

  16. siera says:

    I think social media is a positive(good)thing for my website. It can bring you many visitors. Some of them generate unique traffic for your site! I don’t really know any bad things about social media, except that they sometimes close the service with “404 Error”. Good thing is that they don’t do that often. Many social media websites stay for a long time, except if it’s created with no care what customers need.

Leave a Reply

Site Sponsors

-->

Live Stats

Useful Links

  • Log in
  • Domain FAQ
  • WordPress Themes
  • Domain & Seo Blog Learn about buying and selling domain names, developing websites and find great seo tips and promotion guides for building web site traffic.
  • Free SEO Software The best SEO tool kit and its FREE! Check for popular keywords, search terms, your sites seo… lots more. Use it to optimize your websites.
  • Top Registrars This site provides useful info on domain name registrars. Find lists of cheap registrars, discount coupons and much more.